The issue is probably coming from the Global Content Restriction add-on, you cannot simply “reset” the add-on with a single button. Instead, you have two options: either remove the specific bad rule (recommended) or turn off the add-on entirely.
Here is how to do both.
Option 1: Remove the specific rule (Recommended)
This add-on works by attaching “Global Rules” to your specific Subscription Plans. This is why you couldn’t find a central “Settings” page for it—the settings are hidden inside your plans.
- Go to Paid Member Subscriptions → Subscription Plans.
- Edit each of your plans (e.g., “Gold” or “Free”).
- Scroll down to the bottom of the page to find the Global Content Restriction box.
- Look for a rule that restricts “Post Type: Page” or “Taxonomy”.
- Click the “Remove” or “X” button next to that rule.
- Click Save Subscription.
- Repeat this for every subscription plan you have.
Once you remove the rule from the plan, the global block will disappear, and your individual page settings will work again.
Option 2: Turn off the Add-on (The “Nuclear” Option)
If you don’t use global rules at all and just want to restrict pages manually one by one, you can simply disable this feature.
- Go to Paid Member Subscriptions → Add-ons
- Find Global Content Restriction in the list.
- Click Deactivate.
This effectively “resets” the behavior by stopping the plugin from looking for any global rules.
Next Step: After doing this, clear your cache and check the page in an Incognito window. Did that solve it? Let me know in the comments